October 23, 2020

On a Hiding to Nothing? The Impossible Quest for Neutrality

Is acting as a neutral vessel when facilitating truly a realistic aim? Facilitators are typically trained they should be neutral, staying out of the content of what’s been explored, focussing instead on the process. This makes good sense because group process is so often where things fall down at all manner of different scales: from developing organisational culture, capability and capacity, to specific tools and approaches used to find solutions for specific problems. Organisations can be full of the best minds in the world, but successfully creating value working together is so often where there’s grit in the oil. Good facilitators will help smooth (and often accelerate) the journey. If it’s on the agenda, good facilitation can help people actively engage in making a positive difference to their company, its customers, their colleagues and the communities they serve. Facilitation can play a very powerful role in organisational and cultural change.

The challenge is, anyone who’s been around facilitation for any length of time will know that being 100% neutral is impossible.

Take my sentence above about making a positive difference: what to me is a positive difference may not be to you. I’m taking sides by virtue of my values. We can’t not approach an intervention (and let’s face it, even an off the record discussion with an employee is an intervention) without our frames of reference, our values base, our knowledge and skills having an impact.

We also can’t ‘un-know’ something that we know. When a client comes asking for help supporting some work where they’ve already chosen a linear, engineering response to the challenge, but the challenge exists in the complex domain, I can’t not know that they’d likely end up with a whole load of unintended consequences, and would really be on a hiding to nothing taking the approach they’ve chosen. Here we get caught between facilitator and consultant roles: we add value by educating, and demonstrating in this case why an alternative approach would be more appropriate, but we’re no longer being neutral.

By the way, this is currently a very real challenge: many organisations have been working the way they have for years, have their set best practices and methodologies, and continue to apply them despite the fact that the context they now find themselves in is completely different. Do get in touch if you’d like to know more – it could be what keeps you afloat in challenging times.

Then take for a moment the work we choose to do. At times, for example, we’re approached to do things where it’s clear the sponsor’s strategy is more one of covert coercion than a transparent engagement with the people involved. Do we take the work on because of financial drivers, or share our thoughts and risk not doing the work in order to stay true to our values? Either way, our personal ‘map of the world’ is influencing the system.

When starting out in facilitation around 20 years ago, I was asked to facilitate a medium-term project in a large company. The sponsor’s goals for embarking on the project were well aligned with the company’s strategy, the project leader was very enthusiastic and nice, though perhaps a bit green, and all the key movers and shakers were in the team. All seemed good, so off we went.

Despite strong engagement with all the set-up activities prior to our first meeting, the meeting itself was a bit of a car crash. Lots of very big alpha male characters clashing with each other, and a project leader who seemed out of her depth. A distinctly uncomfortable experience, but some seeds of creative possibilities were emerging.

I discussed the situation with the project leader afterwards, and we decided to meet with the sponsor so she could share progress. He said what we’d experienced was to be expected, don’t worry, they’re always like that, herding cats etc. So, we forged ahead with meeting 2 once the actions from the first had been completed.

It wasn’t a big surprise when the second meeting continued in a similar vein, and I had to reflect some of the behaviours that were impacting progress back to them all. This helped short term, but 20 minutes later the patterns emerged again. Suffice to say progress was challenging.

After a painful workshop I picked up the phone to the sponsor. “Don’t worry about it,” came the reply, “I only did this so I could get sufficient evidence to fire the project leader!”

Oh, how easy it is to fall into the trap of the strategic and political use of facilitation within an organisation. My eyes have been much wider open since. This rather painful lesson made me aware that when it comes to being neutral, we need to keep in mind the political use of our skillset. Again, we can’t not have a degree of influence here, by virtue of the work we choose to do, and the work we turn down. For the more astute and experienced, this is likely a conscious decision, but at times we may still get played.

Then there’s the political side of the organisations we do and don’t work with. Research suggests all organisations are political by virtue of things like the ways conflicts and decisions are managed, who is and is not involved in decision making, and who controls resources (Lawton and Rose, 1994). Power is entrenched in the relationships between actors, and politics come into play as actors mobilise power (Hardy, 1994). When we work in an organisation, we get involved with those who have power, and those who don’t, and have an influence on the relationship between the two, impacting the socio-political dynamic.

Years ago, I helped deal with some conflict between a senior manager and his team. The organisation was cutting its cost base, meaning this team no longer had a room to work in when in the office. They were field based in the morning, but came to the office in the afternoon to deal with paperwork. However now, all they had was the busy contact centre to work in, where they needed to keep quiet. Not a great environment for people who typically needed to blow off steam after mornings working solo extracting rent arrears, during which they’d sometimes get assaulted, or even held hostage. Most were ex-squaddies, great characters doing a very difficult job, but their manager was gradually squeezing them more and more, making their life very hard, and then giving them hell every time they weren’t perfect.

The politics playing out here were around a senior manager doing what he needed to retain power, further subjugating his team. As I spent more time working with the salt of the earth characters involved, I found out what was really at play: the married-with-2-kids senior manager had slept with one of the team, and was now forcing her out. The rest of the team were best mates with her, so he was doing all he could to push them too. Oh boy. He had no intention of stopping the conflict, and engaging me was more an act of being seen to be doing the right thing, when behind the scenes he was sabotaging everything. A very clever political animal, I believe he’s still in power some 16 years on.

What emerges here is the need for transparency. If the quest for neutrality is impossible, the next best thing is to be transparent about our intentions, our reasoning, our decisions, beliefs and values. With an appropriate approach, we can also draw out much of what lies beneath the surface, bringing things hidden in the shadows into the light. In doing so we add huge value.

The organisations we facilitators work with won’t always be transparent, so we’re still at risk of being political pawns, but exercising care, being reflective, and acknowledging that we only have partial awareness are key here. In all my time working in complexity, the one thing we can be sure about is that something we didn't know will emerge.

So how are your skills for developing transparency? If you’re a facilitator, manager or leader who’d like to know more about this fascinating area and the positive impact it can have on your work, do get in touch.

Other Posts

Brain-Friendly Learning
How Zoom Overdoses are Impacting Our Brains
The increase in digital communication due to the pandemic is causing a shift in our brains, impacting on things like creativity and ability to learn. Read on to find out more
Diversity & Inclusion
How equally do we Judge Female and Male Book Covers?
Whoops! New veterinary students mistake world leading research vet for a technician due to her clothes, and most likely a heavy dose of unconscious bias on their part. What do we now need to be doing in schools to support better gender balance in the workplace?
Leadership
Why Generalists are the Secret Ingredient to the Future
Does 2020 mark the start of an era where the balance between specialists and generalists comes more into equilibrium? Will the speed of change and volatility in the marketplace place more demand on generalists? We think so, read on to find out why https://bit.ly/2QXz9FA
Culture Change
How Decision Making Unwittingly Limited the World’s Future
How you make decisions in your organisation has a huge bearing on the longer-term outcomes you bring into being. Yet for most teams and organisations we work with, this area starts out being a blind spot.
Culture Change
Excelling in Distributed Collaboration = Key Competitive Advantage
If you’ve recently moved people to work from home, how well does your culture support it? With such a significant move, without conscious focus your culture can quickly morph, and not necessarily in a good way.
Distributed teams
Why Poor Punctuation could be your Weakest Link
Punctuation is important, right? Without it, a string of words won’t necessarily make sense. The same goes for our work. We need punctuation points over the passage of time in order to keep some sense of reference to what we’re working towards.
Distributed teams
More Control is Not the Answer
Getting your team aligned is one of the most important things you can do as a team leader, particularly when your people work remotely.
Leadership
Lessons in Lockdown Leadership from Z-Cam
Learn how one company has managed to delight their customers during lockdown, with a combination of product development and customer engagement via social media.
Distributed teams
Could you be more specific please?
Remote working puts a magnifying glass on our communication. We’re no longer in the context-rich setting of an office where we pick up a lot through background conversations, non-verbal communication and chance meetings.‍
Distributed teams
Why Remote Teams aren’t all Plain Sailing – and How to Calm the Water #2
Are your results with remote working being limited by the tools you're using? It's a factor many organisations are blind to because they've always worked the way they do.
Diversity & Inclusion
I Refuse
Leaders of the world, are you ready for this generation joining the workplace? Can you even attract them in the first place?
Leadership
Leaders: Right Now You Have Everything to Lose
Tough times bring our values to the fore, like a magnifying glass analysing the degree of alignment between what we say we value and our day-to-day behaviours. If you show any cracks here, it'll come back to bite you...
Furlough
The ONE thing you MUST do with your team as you return from furlough
If you’re bringing furloughed employees back to work soon, have you planned on how you recalibrate your team?
Distributed teams
Why Remote Teams aren’t All Plain Sailing - and How to Calm the Water No. 1
Have you been missing those coffee machine conversations while working remotely? Noticing that the lack of spontaneous communication has an impact on your work and relationships?
Leadership
Gang fights, Bridges and Beer
What have gang fights, bridges and beer have in common? Read on and find out #OpenYourWorld
Leadership
Habitual Power
Habit is the breakfast of champions, but also the undoing of us when we unconsciously get sucked into less than useful habits. So where’s your focus (consciously and unconsciously)? How about the company where you work? What patterns do you notice? Are you a habitually busy person, rarely able to find time to do the important things you know you should? Do you get sucked into the busy-ness of others?
Customer Experience
What an Experience
How's the customer experience with your company? How easy is it for them to do business with you? How do you most want your customers to feel while doing business with you? Anxious, uncertain, annoyed, frustrated? We guess that’d be a no. Yet there are still so many businesses that continue to generate these feelings in their customers.
Inside Out
The Ultimate Accountability Model
We’d like to suggest that the key to solving the angst about migration is to point people to the source of their experience. When countries and individuals realise that their anti-refugee stance is not caused by things that happen on the outside that they may feel a victim of, but by what’s going on with their thinking, then there’s hope.
Customer Experience
What Gets Measured Gets Experienced
You’ve no doubt heard the expression ‘What gets measured gets done’, an adage which seems to hold true because the things we’re measured against typically drive our focus and behaviour. We’d like to offer a slight - but important - adaptation of this: what gets measured gets experienced. Bear with me on this: I’m not sure if it holds true all the time, and I’m sharing something here that’s still in its formative stages. However, as customer experience is becoming more and more of a differentiator amongst businesses I think it’s well worthwhile trying this modified mantra on for size.
Customer Experience
Come On Retail, Retaliate!
Is it all gloom and doom in the retail sector? Sir Charlie Mayfield, chairman of the British Retail Consortium, warned last week that the retail sector is facing the loss of up to 900,000 jobs and thousands of shop closures in the coming decade. This in part due to the new apprenticeship levy and the rise in the National Living Wage. Over in Europe things aren’t much different, with Swiss retailers in particular feeling the pinch due to the strong franc and the ease of buying the same product in the Eurozone at much lower prices.
Culture Change
Done Lean - Six Sigma? Didn't really work?
Lots of companies say they’ve ‘done’ Lean, ‘done’ Six Sigma, and with this there’s very often an associated ‘and it didn’t really work for us’ attached. When we probe a bit further, it soon transpires that whilst they had a go at it, there were lots of required ingredients that weren’t in place, and naturally, rather like baking a chocolate cake without the chocolate or cocoa, the result didn’t meet expectations. Want to get the best from applying Lean - Six Sigma in your business? Read on.
Customer Experience
Small Words, Big Impact
Changing small words can have a big impact on outcomes. Discover some of the helpful recent findings from the world of Conversational Analysis, particularly applicable in the worlds of customer experience, negotiating, sales and general consulations.
Inside Out
The Curious David Bowie Effect
Fundamentally, this is what’s behind everything that prevents us realising our full potential: things like stress, overwhelm, anxiety, office politics, levels of busy-ness, baggage from previous encounters and so on. The performance of an organisation is a function of the quality of its people’s thinking. When the quality and clarity of thinking improves, great things happen.
Culture Change
Bringing About Organisational Change
An interview with Alastair Olby on bringing about change in organisations. When do traditional methods work, and when could you be making life easier by taking more of a cutting edge approach?
Customer Experience
To Delight or Not Frustrate? That is the Question
There’s a world of difference between a customer experience-focussed company and a customer service-focussed company: it’s a profound cultural difference, and to make the shift from one to the other isn’t necessarily easy, but it IS possible.
Facilitating
Graphic Recording and Groups: how much value does it add?
As a professional facilitator I’m very aware of the importance and value of visually summarising what’s being discussed by groups, but at the recent European International Association of Facilitators’ conference an interesting question arose. It seems to have become best practice to have a graphics expert work alongside groups to create a visual summary of what the group discusses. However for some it's not always easy to recall what's depicted. So what should we do?
Customer Experience
What Have Dignity And Respect Got To Do With It?
Recently a large organisation we work with launched a Dignity and Respect workshop for its staff. Why? Well customer feedback suggested that this was an area for improvement. The workshop took 90 minutes and underlined why it's so important for customers to be treated well, and the sorts of behaviours that are expected of the organisation's staff. The result? Fuming staff. Read on to find out why.
Leadership
I'm Honest, Right?
The one thing followers most want from a leader is honesty. Honesty ranks head and shoulders above all the other wants of followers. It's the number one thing to get right, yet many leaders in large organisations inadvertently create an impression of dishonesty. Read on to find out how this happens.
Diversity & Inclusion
Are You Ready For The Inclusion Challenge?
Did you know that despite the economic gloom around much of the world, at the moment engineers are in short supply? With emerging markets' need for qualified, skilled engineers, many organisations are having to re-evaluate their approach to recruiting and retaining talented staff, casting the net far wider than before. This then creates challenges with ensuring people from very different backgrounds feel included in the workplace.
Culture Change
Are Meetings Taking Over Your Life?
So many people are finding there's precious little time to do their normal job after all the meetings they have to attend. Read on to find out how come core principles for meetings can make a big improvement.
Leadership
Are You Working For A Psychopath?
Surely not! But wait on a minute. Recent research for the film 'The Corporation' concludes that the closest character definition of a typical corporation is that of a psychopath. So can working within organisational values result in decent people doing things which are collectively harmful?
Customer Experience
Is This The Same Hotel?
Do your customers experience variation in the quality of your service or product? In the age of the experience economy, and the need to focus on customer experience, not customer service, this is such an important area. How does your company stack up?